South Africa Cannot Afford to Lose Ground in the Global Race for Talent: A Full Review of Its Critical Skills List Is Urgent | Xpatweb

South Africa Cannot Afford to Lose Ground in the Global Race for Talent: A Full Review of Its Critical Skills List Is Urgent

For more than 30% of multinational employers and large corporates operating in South Africa the absence from the national Critical Skills List of occupations for which they need to recruit internationally, is hindering their ability to attract foreign talent. This is significant because only occupations included on the List qualify skilled professionals for a Critical Skills Work Visa to live and work in the country.

FEATURED IN

Marisa Jacobs, Managing Director of Xpatweb, says this finding from the Xpatweb 2026 Critical Skills Survey that the List does not cater for the scarce skills companies have to attract from abroad, highlights why the Critical Skills List must remain relevant and reflect the current skills most in demand in the labour market.

Where an occupation is not recognised on the Critical Skills List, employers looking to recruit a foreign professional may have to pursue a General Work Visa. This involves a separate application process under the points-based system assessing qualifications, work experience and language proficiency, and generally takes longer than the Critical Skills Work Visa application.

How Immigration Policy Can Keep Pace

The survey, recognised as the most comprehensive of its kind among verified employers, found that 67% of employers must search globally for the critical skills their businesses need. This requires a responsive immigration framework to ensure that South Africa is competitive in attracting foreign talent.

According to Jacobs, the latest survey findings reinforce the need for a comprehensive overhaul of the Critical Skills List to align with evolving labour requirements and enable employers to access scarce international skills for occupations which are precisely listed.

“In today’s fast-changing world of work, the List can quickly become outdated. We believe it should be reviewed as frequently as every two or three years, to keep pace with employers’ demands, rather than allowing years to pass between full reviews.”

Historically, South Africa has seen lengthy gaps between full reviews of its Critical Skills List, like the seven-year interval between the 2014 and 2022 lists, with interim amendments in August 2022 and in October 2023 when a number of occupations were added.

The Minister of Home Affairs said in a written parliamentary answer in July 2026 that the lifespan of a critical skills list is ordinarily five years. The current list, with 142 occupations, is expected to be reviewed in 2027.

Jacobs welcomed the Minister’s indication of the imminent review in 2027, but says the question going forward is whether South Africa can afford to wait that long, particularly when other countries regularly reassess their occupational shortage lists and skilled migration frameworks.

Survey Results Call Attention to Mismatches  

Drawing on responses from almost 400 employers, the Xpatweb Critical Skills Survey point out specific gaps where the current Critical Skills List do not directly recognise by name occupations needed by businesses. The specific name of an occupation is a prerequisite to obtain a Critical Skills Work Visa.

The data shows that:

  • 13 of the 20 roles employers name most often as hard to recruit, do not appear on the Critical Skills List. A 14th occupation, Cybersecurity Analyst, has only a related entry as ICT Security Specialist.
  • Across all 174 roles in the survey questions, 45% of mentions related to roles that do not appear on the list.  

Jacobs says occupations that have no direct listing, are particularly concentrated in some of the fastest-moving areas of the economy, including artificial intelligence (AI), data and digital technology.

The broader survey findings point to growing pressure in several of these key skills categories. Demand for ICT specialists has reached an all-time high, with 26% of employers reporting shortages in this area. Meanwhile, 27% of respondents report difficulty in finding engineers and 21% of companies are struggling to recruit AI and emerging technology expertise.

Although several engineer occupations are included on the list, automation engineers and maintenance engineers are absent.

Among the 7 AI and emerging technology occupations most often mentioned in the survey, none appear on the List by its specific occupational title. These include AI/Machine Learning Engineer, Applied AI Specialist, Data Engineer, Cloud Engineer and Solutions Architect.

While Data Scientist is included, other important roles in the data pipeline, such as Data Analyst and Data Engineer, are not.

“This illustrates how occupational requirements are evolving and why the List needs regular updating to reflect the full range of skills in demand across emerging industries,” says Jacobs.

The aviation sector provides another example. Pilot occupations, ranging from Cadet Pilot to Training Captain, are not included on the List, despite being identified by employers as occupations experiencing skills shortage. The demand for aviation professionals in South Africa reflects a global trend, with Boeing’s Pilot and Technician Outlook 2026–2045 projecting a need for approximately 674,000 new pilots and more than 720,000 new maintenance technicians to support the global commercial aviation fleet over the next 20 years[1].

The Business Cost of Absent Skills

Recruiting professionals whose skills are not listed on the Critical Skills List comes at a cost for businesses.

According to the Xpatweb 2026 Critical Skills Survey vacancies materially affect 72% of employers: 20% cited a severe impact and another 52% a significant impact on business operations as unfilled roles limit output, postpone expansion and delay project implementation, undermining business growth.

The Value of Employer Insights

In 2024, the International Labour Organization (ILO), in collaboration with the Southern Africa Migration Management (SAMM) project, presented an evaluation of South Africa’s Critical Skills List to the National Economic Development and Labour Council (NEDLAC).

While the evaluation found that the List aligned with national strategic objectives, it also identified opportunities to make it more responsive to evolving labour market needs. Among its recommendations were incorporating qualitative inputs throughout the List’s development process and updating it more frequently.

Jacobs says the findings of the Xpatweb 2026 Critical Skills Survey, representing the collective voice of participating employers, will be communicated to the relevant government entities to help ensure that the List more accurately reflects labour market realities and make provision for the skills businesses source internationally.

“With the next review of the List approaching and an extensive research and consultation process ahead, this is an important opportunity to put employers’ experiences and evidence of skills shortages before Government to help inform the revised List. In the long run, this positions South Africa as opening its doors to foreign skilled professionals essential to support sustained economic growth.”

CONTACT US

Scroll to Top